Subtext promised Pralltown $3 million to build near UK. Its announcement doesn’t mention Pralltown.

🌎 Resumen en español · traducción automática

Subtext desarrollará EVER Lexington, una torre de 520 camas para estudiantes en la esquina de South Limestone y Prall Street, frente a la Universidad de Kentucky, tras comprar cinco parcelas por 12.2 millones de dólares en agosto. El proyecto fue aprobado por el Consejo Urbano-Condado en marzo con 491 camas tras acordar Subtext pagar 3 millones de dólares a la Asociación de Vecinos de Pralltown, aunque el comunicado de prensa no menciona el nombre de la zona Pralltown ni especifica las direcciones exactas de las parcelas compradas.

Traducción y resumen generados por IA a partir del artículo en inglés. Puede contener errores; consulte el texto original.

To win approval for a student apartment tower across from the University of Kentucky, a St. Louis developer promised the Pralltown Neighborhood Association $3 million. The city agreed not to issue a building permit until the money is paid.

On Monday the developer, Subtext, announced the project to the public. The announcement runs about 900 words. It does not mention Pralltown, the historically Black neighborhood that fought the project for more than a year, and it does not mention the $3 million.

It does say the building will have 520 beds. The city council approved the rezoning on a plan for 491.

Subtext’s news release says it has bought land at “565 S Limestone” for a project called EVER Lexington: a seven-story building with 149 apartments, a pool deck, a sauna and about 4,000 square feet of shops on the ground floor. Construction is set to start this fall, with tenants moving in by summer 2028.

Public records fill in what the release leaves out.

The land deal

There is no address at 565 S. Limestone. The property is five lots at the corner of South Limestone, Prall Street and Montmullin Street: 545-549, 553 and 563 S. Limestone, 121-123 Prall St. and 118 Montmullin St. Together they cover about 0.83 acres.

A company called EVER Lexington Limestone LLC bought the lots Aug. 7 for $12,212,500, according to deeds filed with the Fayette County Clerk on Aug. 11. The company was formed in Delaware in April and lists Subtext’s St. Louis headquarters as its address.

The county assesses the same five lots at $2,613,800. Subtext paid 4.7 times that, or about $23,500 for each bed it plans to build.

The sellers were Warehouses KY LLC of Nicholasville, formed in 2012 by Donald L. Ware Jr. and Lorea Ware to hold storefronts and lots they bought between 1990 and 1994, and Gordon Bentley, who had owned 553 S. Limestone since 1980. No loan against the property had been recorded as of Sunday.

A year and a half of fighting

Pralltown dates to the years after the Civil War. John A. Prall, a lawyer and state senator, divided the land into lots between 1868 and 1877 and sold them to formerly enslaved people. By 1880 the neighborhood had 290 Black residents and 46 white ones. The city tried twice to clear it for redevelopment, in the early 1950s and again from 1968 to 1974. Both efforts failed.

Subtext first came to the city in 2024 with a much bigger plan. It asked to rezone 2.13 acres reaching deep into the neighborhood for a building of 251 apartments and 799 beds, about 108 feet tall. The plan was called “Verve Lexington” at the time.

Bruce Simpson, the lawyer for the Pralltown Neighborhood Association, told the Planning Commission on Oct. 24, 2024, that the project was “a major gentrification on steroids.” The commission voted 6-3 to recommend against it. The Urban County Council deadlocked 7-7 on whether to take it up, then voted 11-3 to drop it. The rejection became final in January 2025.

Subtext came back in late 2025 with a smaller building on a smaller piece of land. The new plan asked to rezone only about half an acre behind the Limestone storefronts. The building would be eight stories and 90 feet tall, with 170 apartments and 491 beds. It would no longer reach the houses behind it.

The 2024 plan had included an offer of 16 affordable apartments or $1.5 million for the city’s affordable housing fund. That offer was gone. Asked about it, Subtext development manager Ryan Bumb said, “Through the discussions with the neighborhood, we’ve chosen other priorities as the benefits.”

The $3 million promise

What replaced it was a two-page letter from Subtext’s lawyer, Nick Nicholson, dated Jan. 29, 2026. In it, Subtext promised three things: to keep the project to the size in its application and never seek to rezone any more of the neighborhood, to give the neighborhood association 30 days’ notice of any new plans, and to pay the Pralltown Neighborhood Association $3 million before getting a building permit.

Clause (c) of the Jan. 29, 2026 letter from Subtext's attorney: pay the Pralltown Neighborhood Association $3,000,000 before any building permit. — The $3 million clause in the Jan. 29, 2026, letter from Subtext’s attorney, attached to the city ordinance. The city agreed to hold building permits until the money is paid.

Teresa Forbes Lopez, a Pralltown resident and association board member, told the commission the neighborhood supported the new plan “when it is conditioned upon clear, enforceable guidelines that directly address the impact of the development.”

The Planning Commission approved the rezoning 9-0. The council passed it 15-0 on March 12. Council member Tyler Morton called it “what real community engagement looks like at its best.”

But the ordinance the council passed contains no limit on beds, apartments or height. It says the city “is not a party” to the $3 million deal and that the rezoning “is not conditioned upon” it. The city’s only commitment is to hold building permits until it is told the terms have been met. The only document that ties the project to 491 beds is Subtext’s own letter.

The number went up

On April 6, less than four weeks after the council vote, Subtext filed its final construction plan with the city. The plan lists 155 apartments and 525 beds, 34 more beds than the council was shown. The building grew 4 feet, to 94, and the garage shrank from 215 spaces to 170. The city does not require any parking at the site.

City planners noticed. Their April 29 review asked Subtext to explain the “increase in lot coverage, building square footage, number of bedrooms and height of building.” The Planning Commission approved the plan anyway on May 14, with 12 conditions. None of them limited the number of beds.

Monday’s release, at 520 beds, tracks that final plan, not the one the council approved. Whether 525 beds fits the letter’s promise to keep the project to the size in its application is a question for the neighborhood association, which is the other party to the deal, and for the city’s Law Department, which holds the permits. The Lexington Times has asked the association, Subtext and the city and will update this story if they respond.

Work has already begun on paper. Subtext filed to combine the five lots into one on Aug. 12, the day after the deeds were recorded, and filed demolition permits for the three Limestone storefronts on Aug. 17. No building permit is on file.

Who is paying

The release says the site is in a “qualified opportunity zone.” That is true. Opportunity zones are a federal tax break: investors who put capital gains into a project in a designated zone can delay taxes on those gains and pay nothing on the project’s profits after 10 years. The Pralltown lots are in Fayette County census tract 9, one of seven Lexington tracts designated in 2018. Subtext’s other Lexington project, the 784-bed VERVE Lexington on East Maxwell Street, is in an opportunity zone too.

Nationally, 78 percent of opportunity-zone money has gone to 5 percent of the zones, and about two-thirds of it has gone into real estate, construction and hotels, according to federal data compiled by the Urban Institute.

Subtext’s money partner is Larson Capital Management, the real estate arm of a St. Louis firm that manages money for doctors and dentists. It reports $1.43 billion under management. For Subtext’s towers at Texas A&M, Larson raised money by selling shares to individual investors with a $25,000 minimum, according to a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Its sales pitch for that project put the cost at $353 million, or about $203,100 per bed. No such filing for the Lexington project had appeared as of Monday.

A claim that doesn’t hold up

The release says the site is “at the center of the university’s $2.4 billion campus expansion zone.” The $2.4 billion is UK HealthCare’s hospital expansion, approved in 2023: a new tower at Chandler Hospital, a cancer center and four clinics around the region. Chandler is about half a mile south of Pralltown. The site is across the street from Memorial Hall, the Gatton College of Business and the College of Law. That is a good location. It is not the same claim.

The bigger picture

EVER Lexington is one of three large student housing projects now approved or under construction within a mile of campus. With VERVE Lexington’s 784 beds and the 655-bed MXWL on East Maxwell, which opens in 2027, that is 1,964 new beds. A fourth project, Up Campus’s 725-bed proposal on East High Street, goes to the Planning Commission in September. The council rejected a 1,010-bed Hub project on Maxwell Street last November, and a 260-bed plan for the Woodland Triangle was withdrawn in June.

Pralltown got something those other neighborhoods did not: a written promise, a notice requirement and $3 million, backed by a city that says it will not issue a permit until the check clears. What it did not get was a bed count in the law. The rendering in Monday’s release is of a building the council never saw.

Correction to prior coverage: The Lexington Times’ Aug. 15 Reddit roundup described Subtext as “proposing” an 800-bed building at this corner with a rezoning hearing in September. That was wrong. The 800-bed version was rejected in 2024; the 491-bed rezoning was approved March 12, 2026; and the September Planning Commission item is Up Campus’s East High Street project. The roundup has been corrected.

Sources for this story include Fayette County deed records, Fayette PVA records, Kentucky Secretary of State filings, city zoning files PLN-MAR-24-00014, PLN-MAR-25-00022 and PLN-MJDP-26-00027, Planning Commission and council meeting records in The Lexington Times’ LFUCG meeting archive, and SEC filings. The full document set is at feeds.lexingtonky.news/media/lfucg-meeting-archive/ever-lexington/. Subtext’s release and the rendering were provided by Quinn PR.

Sources

This story was reported and drafted with AI assistance (claude-fable-5) by The Lexington Times newsroom system and reviewed before publication. Reporting is grounded in the Fayette County Clerk deed index, Fayette PVA records, Kentucky Secretary of State filings, LFUCG Legistar and Accela records, Planning Commission and council transcripts and minutes via The Lexington Times meeting archive and Granicus, SEC filings, and the linked sources. The ordinance excerpt shown is a crop of the recorded document; the rendering was supplied by the developer.

View in feeds

Republishing: This is original Lexington Times reporting, licensed under Creative Commons CC BY-ND 4.0. You may republish this article, in full and unaltered, for free — including commercially — with credit to The Lexington Times and a link to the original.